OpinionMediation – a comparison between UK and US mediations

Mediation – a comparison between UK and US mediations

-

- Advertisment -sslate

Chester-based Manleys solicitors virtually mediated a case in New York, USA.  Here, Mark Manley, MD at the firm comments on some interesting differences in mediation procedures and practices between the UK and USA.

He said: “The first thing we noticed was that the top mediators command significantly higher fees in the US.  We were quoted some eye-watering fee scales.  Then the pre-mediation procedure was really quite different.  The parties do NOT exchange Position Statements.  Each provides a private statement to the mediator.

Whilst additional “for your eyes only” confidential statements are common in the UK, the notion of not exchanging anything at all pre-mediation was something of a surprise, and not helpful as it just elongates the process.

Instead of this exchange we were invited to a pre-mediation discussion – not just with the mediator but with the opponent (without client attendance from either side).

UK US mediation

It’s all very “keep your cards close to your chest” rather than full and frank exchange so each side knows the case they have to meet.”

“Then the complete lack of any disclosure pre-mediation also caused delay on the day of the mediation itself.  Our US opponents didn’t contribute anything to the mediation bundle at all.

As a result, old-style ‘ambushing’ is fully in play in mediations with a US opponent – where “surprise” documents come to light for the first time during the mediation process.”

The negotiation phase of the mediation also presented something new.

Manley explains: “The American lawyers and mediators are big fans of “bracketed” offers.

So instead of making an offer of an amount it is more “if your client is willing to accept an offer in a bracket between $x – $y”, our client is willing to pay an amount in a bracket between $A – $B”.

Manley continued:  “I’ve now mediated nearly 1000 cases since becoming an accredited mediator 25 years ago – but I’d not come across this before.  There is a wholly different psychological approach to offers in brackets rather than precise amounts.  It took a bit of working out and the moment of digression from brackets to specifics caused a lot of problems.”

Finally, Manley notes the quasi-judicial role US mediators are willing to adopt.  The mediation ended successfully but instead of either blind bids, crossover bids, or one of the “usual” methods of breaking stalemate, the mediator was willing to convert from facilitation to active participation in determining the amount of damages.

Not that far removed from Early Neutral Evaluation, it was a variation of Mediator non-binding evaluation of a claim with an element of “blind” acceptance/offer which I found both novel, risky but very effective.

I’m not sure how parties in disputes in the UK would be willing to embrace it but it certainly worked and I might at least offer it as part of my mediation practice going forwards”

The past 12 months has seen Manleys involved in litigation/disputes in the USA, Singapore, Finland, Switzerland, Dubai, Albania, South Africa and Germany.  Managing Director, Mark Manley appeared as counsel in an Appeal in the Southern District of New York in 2023.

So the firm is becoming used to having to grapple with foreign jurisdictions, but the UK/US mediation last week was a first.

Manley concluded “I enjoyed it.  The time differences made life a bit tough for the clients – we had 4 different time zones to deal with – parties in Texas and Dubai and Lawyers in New York and here in the UK.  So 9 hours difference at most.  It made for a late night for some of us!”

Sunshine Slate
Sunshine Slatehttps://www.sunshineslate.com
Sunshine Slate is your news, entertainment, music fashion website. We provide you with the latest breaking news and videos straight from the United States of America.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

How Growing Florida Communities Can Plan Wastewater Capacity

Key Takeaways Wastewater capacity should be planned before growth creates service constraints. Florida communities need to account for seasonal...

Turbocharger Oil Supply Lines: Installation Tips and Mistakes to Avoid

Ever wondered why some turbos last for years while others fail within months, hence the need for a good car repair center.

7 Myths About Stretching Equipment In Australia

7 Myths About Stretching Equipment in Australia Most people get stretching equipment wrong before they even start using it

SLYNUMBER Gives Consumers More Confidence in Financial Texts with Verified Origination

MobileSphere, a leading provider of worldwide mobile communications, today announced Verified Origination for SLYNUMBER
- Advertisement -

Choosing Rustic Furniture That Combines Practicality With Timeless Design

Have you ever walked into a room and instantly felt at home? That warm, inviting atmosphere where every piece of furniture tells a story?

A Practical Phoenix, Arizona Neighborhood Scorecard for Home Buyers

Buyers comparing homes for sale in Phoenix can use 1912 Realty's Phoenix listing resource to view available properties alongside neighborhood guides and local area information.
edealo.com
- Advertisement -sslate
transformerscon

Must read

U.S. removes Francisco D’Agostino from sanctions list after confirming no ties to Venezuelan regime

U.S. Department of the Treasury has officially removed Francisco D’Agostino, brother-in-law of Luis Alfonso de Borbón, from SDN List

National Medal of Honor Day: Honoring Florida heroes and their legacy

National Medal of Honor Day, a time to reflect on the extraordinary bravery and sacrifice of the fewer than 4,000 Americans who have received the nation's highest military honor.
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -sslate

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you