[Tallahassee, FL] A House committee Tuesday approved a revised proposal that would allow agencies to randomly drug test state employees, as a federal judge prepares to hear arguments Wednesday about a similar testing plan by Gov. Rick Scott.

Debate in the House Appropriations Committee focused heavily on whether the proposal (HB 1205) is constitutional. Sponsor Rep. Jimmie Smith (R-43/Inverness) said he is confident the bill would be upheld.

“It is my opinion that this bill is absolutely and 100 percent constitutional,” Smith said.

But Pamela Burch Fort, a lobbyist for the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida, and other opponents made clear that the bill would face a constitutional challenge if lawmakers approve it.

“I took an oath to uphold the constitution, and I think this bill violates the constitution,” said House Minority Leader Ron Saunders (D-120/Key West).

The bill stalled last week in the appropriations committee, but Smith offered an amendment Tuesday that would limit random drug testing to a maximum of 10 percent of an agency’s employees. Also, agencies would not be required to drug test state employees, as funding would have to come from within agency budgets – not extra money.

“If they do not have the money, they do not do the program,” Smith said.

Photo: FL House

Rep. Jimmie Smith sponsored a bill to randomly drug test state employees

The committee voted 15-8 to approve the bill. Rep. Ed Hooper (R-50/Clearwater) was the only Republican to vote against the bill; Rep. Darryl Rouson (D-55/St. Petersburg) was the only Democrat to vote for it.

Scott issued an executive order last year requiring Florida to drug test state employees but was quickly hit with a constitutional challenge that the ACLU filed on behalf of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees. The ACLU said oral arguments are scheduled Wednesday afternoon in a Miami federal courthouse.

Burch Fort said Smith’s amendment Tuesday does not make the bill more constitutional and suggested lawmakers should wait to consider the issue until after a ruling in the Scott lawsuit.

“Nothing has changed,” she said. “House Bill 1205 remains unconstitutional.”

But Rouson, who has openly discussed his past drug abuse, said he thinks the bill doesn’t go far enough.

“Why is anybody afraid of being tested for the ingestion of illegal drugs in the workplace?” Rouson asked.

By: The News Service of Florida

Lead image: Brandon Giesbrecht

drug test state employees

[Orlando, FL] A federal judge in Orlando has put a stop – at least temporarily – to Gov. Rick Scott‘s highly touted (and highly controversial) requirement that those seeking cash assistance from the state take a drug test at their own expense.

On Monday, Judge Mary Scriven issued the ruling based on her opinion that the new law may be a violation of the Constitution’s ban on unreasonable searches and seizures, according to a report by The Huffington Post. The judge will hold a full hearing on the law, but until then – the tests will not be required.

“This potential interception of positive drug tests by law enforcement implicates a ‘far more substantial’ invasion of privacy than in ordinary civil drug testing cases,” said Scriven, an appointee of President George W. Bush.

Gov. Scott’s office, which touted huge savings and a moral triumph from the welfare reform law, cannot be pleased.

“The governor obviously disagrees with the decision and he will evaluate his options regarding when to appeal,” Scott spokesperson Jackie Schutz was quoted as saying by The Huffington Post.

By: Mark Christopher/Sunshine Slate

Image: Mark Christopher/Sunshine Slate Images

Resource: The Huffington Post

Related reading:

Unreasonable drug testing  Rick Scott, who promoted the ill-advised tests, backs off the policy before more money is wasted defending it in court. The judge temporarily suspended the drug testing requirement, faulting the fact that results lack confidentiality and noting that …

Michael Mayo: Judge makes right call in halting Florida welfare drug testing Rick Scott (a lawyer) from pushing the program and the lawmakers in the Legislature from approving it earlier this year. The program, which began July 1, was particularly mean-spirited in requiring welfare applicants to pay for their own drug tests up …

Tell ‘Hot Button’ what you think about drug-testing welfare recipients A federal judge has temporarily blocked enforcement of a new law in Florida that requires recipients of welfare benefits to pass a drug test. The judge said the law may violate the US Constitution’s ban on unreasonable searches and seizures. …